A very WIP tier list of every single song in the Guilty Gear Series. Unlike every other tier list, in which I simply go based on my feelings towards each song, I am using a points system to rank them. A song gets from 0 - 1 points in each catagory, and then the total is averaged. The scoring system is as follows:
Melody
Evolution
Emotion (x2)
"Bangerness" (x2)
Characterization
Lyrics
Bread on Fire Bonus
The main melody of the song. Is it good? Is it memorable?
How much does the song change near the end? It doesn't necessarily need to be a complete instrument change, just a cool or meaningful change.
How much emotion does the song give off? I consider this to be one of the most important things, so it is worth double points.
Hard to explain, but just... how good the song is. How energetic it is. Is it a "banger".
How does it characterize the character? Does it fit them at all? For example, a sad song for a sad character. (Lyrics not included)
Are the lyrics good? Do they fit the character? Do I want to scream them into the void?
Did the song get screwed over by the points system? For example, does it have more emotion that a 1 can possible show? Is it good despite only having a high score in one category? Do I want to give it a different score for... reasons?