Did you know I love Bedman? In case it wasn't already obvious, he is my favorite character of all time. This was his first (and, depending on how you see his story, last) theme. It's really good!
Melody
The use of the music box is a great idea. The main melody is very good. I like the addition of the piano.
Evolution
Evolves very well. Fits perfectly. There could theoretically be a bit more, but this works very well.
Emotion
I will fully admit that a lot of the emotion is only there due to my love for Bedman as a character. Most people probably wouldn't find this much emotion in this song. Either way, I find the refrain, instrument choices, and ending to all be emotional.
Bangerness
The refrain is really good. The end is EXCELLENT.
Characterization
Really good. The music box is an excellent addition. The piano during the slow parts fits with the mystery and dreamlike qualities surrounding him. The bells do the same. The emotion given to the refrain also represents the tragedy of Bedman's story well. The slow part near the end does the same, as the piano just has a faint sadness and unease behind it.
Lyrics
-
B.O.F. Bonus
-
Bread 
